• About
    • Privacy Policy
  • GSW
  • Guide To Making A Subject Access Request
  • In Dad’s Shoes
    • An Overview
    • Invitation
    • Media
    • Photos
    • Press Release
    • Soft Launch
    • Speeches
    • Summary
  • Media Coverage
  • Parliamentary Debates
  • Voice of the Child Podcasts

Researching Reform

Researching Reform

Daily Archives: December 18, 2020

Virtual Child Protection Conferences Vetoed By Parents

18 Friday Dec 2020

Posted by Natasha in Researching Reform

≈ 9 Comments

Findings from a survey produced by King’s College London of more than 500 professionals and parents found that while almost 50% of child welfare professionals preferred virtual hearings, all of the parents polled said they preferred physical meetings.

The research was gathered by the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory, and published on 14 December. Of the total people polled, 492 were child welfare professionals, with just 24 respondents being parents.

Key findings from the report include:

  • Three quarters of parents thought the way the conference had been conducted had adversely affected their ability to contribute;
  • Just over half felt they had been able to express their views and comment on what was being said, while the remainder of parents polled believed they had been denied that opportunity or were not able to comment;
  • Nearly half of professionals thought that a virtual model for conferences was better than being in the same room as it enabled a wider range of professionals to attend and;
  • Some professionals reported better engagement with children, particularly older children, in remote conferences, and also that remote conferences could be less intimidating for parents.

Findings echo existing research in this area, which highlight ongoing barriers for vulnerable parents, particularly those with learning complexities, and outline the current tensions between the need for robust support and tech benefits that arise for professionals looking to cut through their case loads.

As is often the way though, this is, for the moment at least, a case of more haste less speed – and a dose of law breaking thrown in.

And these hearings are breaking the law. A previous report published by the Nuffield Foundation found that mothers were having their children removed from them shortly after birth, through telephone hearings and sometimes without the mother present.

That particular survey, which gathered the views of 1,300 individuals did not include a significant amount of family feedback – only 10% of respondents were parents and family members.

The research also found that 40% of parents did not understand what was happening during their remote hearings, while 66% said their cases had not been dealt with well through the online hearing process. Only 12% of parents and relatives polled said they had no concerns about their remote hearing.

The findings of that survey led to a call to ban telephone hearings by family support group, the Parent, Family and Allies Network (PFAN).

And all of this is happening while government policy continues to allow Covid-safe, face-to-face contact.

Virtual family court hearings are also posing challenges for journalists. A recent case involving Haringey Council and PA Media Group caught the media’s attention after details of the council’s shocking child protection failings were revealed, but what has since come to light thanks to this case, is that the media are not being notified of hearings being held remotely.

When Researching Reform wrote about this development in June, we urged the President of the Family Division to explore this phenomenon, and address it.

The lack of family engagement in these research projects is also concerning. We encourage research bodies to find holistic ways to increase parent and family member engagement in this kind of data collection, otherwise, it is almost useless.

Additional Links:

  • New research raises concerns about experiences of parents and families in newly ‘virtual’ child protection conferences – 14th Dec 2020
  • Remote family court hearings are breaking the law – there is a better way (October 2020)
  • What Are Remote Family Court Hearings Really Like For Parents? – Voice of the Child Podcast (May 2020)
  • PA Media Group v London Borough of Haringey & Others [2020] EWHC 1282 (Fam) (May 2020)

Share this:

  • WhatsApp
  • Pocket
  • Telegram
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email
  • Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 8,452 other subscribers

Contact Researching Reform

Huff Post Contributer

For Litigants in Person

Child Welfare Debates

December 2020
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
« Nov   Jan »

Children In The Vine : Stories From The Family Justice System

Categories

  • Adoption
  • All Party Parliamentary Group on Family Law and The Court of Protection
  • Articles
  • Big Data
  • Bills
  • Case Study
  • child abuse
  • child abuse inquiry
  • child welfare
  • Children
  • Children In The Vine
  • Circumcision
  • Civil Partnerships
  • Consultation
  • Conversations With…
  • Corporal Punishment
  • CSA
  • CSE
  • Data Pack
  • Domestic Violence
  • Encyclopaedia on Family and The Law
  • event
  • Family Law
  • Family Law Cases
  • FGM
  • FOI
  • forced adoption
  • Foster Care
  • Fudge of the Week
  • Fultemian Project
  • Huffington Post
  • Human Rights
  • IGM
  • Inquiry
  • Interesting Things
  • Interview
  • Judge of the Week
  • Judges
  • judicial bias
  • Law to lust for
  • legal aid
  • LexisNexis Family Law
  • LIP Service
  • LIPs
  • Marriage
  • McKenzie Friends
  • MGM
  • News
  • Notes
  • petition
  • Picture of the Month
  • Podcast
  • Question It
  • Random Review
  • Real Live Interviews
  • Research
  • Researching Reform
  • social services
  • social work
  • Spotlight
  • Stats
  • Terrorism
  • The Buzz
  • The Times
  • Troubled Families Programme
  • Twitter Conversations
  • Update
  • Voice of the Child
  • Voice of the Child Podcast
  • Westminster Debate
  • Who's Who Cabinet Ministers
  • Your Story

Recommended

  • Blawg Review
  • BlogCatalog
  • DaddyNatal
  • DadsHouse
  • Divorce Survivor
  • Enough Abuse UK
  • Family Law Week
  • Family Lore
  • Flawbord
  • GeekLawyer's Blog
  • Head of Legal
  • Just for Kids Law
  • Kensington Mums
  • Law Diva
  • Legal Aid Barristers
  • Lib Dem Lords
  • Lords of The Blog
  • Overlawyered
  • PAIN
  • Paul Bernal's Blog
  • Public Law Guide
  • Pupillage Blog
  • Real Lawyers Have Blogs
  • Story of Mum
  • Sue Atkins, BBC Parenting Coach
  • The Barrister Blog
  • The Magistrate's Blog
  • The Not So Big Society
  • Tracey McMahon
  • UK Freedom of Information Blog
  • WardBlawg

Archives

  • Follow Following
    • Researching Reform
    • Join 813 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Researching Reform
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: