Children who experience the UK’s care system are twice as likely to die earlier than children who remain with their parents, a study has revealed.
The research was led by professor Amanda Sacker at University College London’s (UCL) institute of epidemiology and healthcare and tracked more than 350,000 people between 1971 and 2013, using government data.
The study, entitled, “The health and well-being of adults who had been in care up to 40 years earlier: are there differences by type of care?” was published in September 2018, but has since been followed by other long-term studies which also paint a stark picture of outcomes for children who enter Britain’s care system.
A report published in 2019 by Christian Munthe, a bioethics professor at Gothenburg University, found that foster care systems in the UK, other parts of Europe and the US adversely affected children’s development, and did not appear to offer better outcomes when compared to children who were raised in ‘adverse’ birth family environments.
Professor Sacker’s report found that over a 42-year period, adults who had experienced the care system as children were 70% more likely to die prematurely than those who had not spent time in care.
She also noted that while there had been a 40% increased risk for children who had been in care compared with those living with parents in 1971, this had surged to 360% in 2001.
The study also found that the likelihood of dying early had doubled in recent years, though the researchers were unable to determine the cause, or causes, of that increase.
The research highlights incidents relating to mental illness like self harm, as the number one cause of premature deaths among care experienced people.
Other conclusions in the report include the confirmation that the researchers’ findings could not be explained by childhood demographic and socioeconomic background, and that decades after children and youths were placed in out-of-home care, they were still likely to report worse health than children who grew up in parental households.
None of this will come as a shock to child protection reformers, who are all too aware that the system is in need of a cultural, training and evidence-based practice rehaul.
You can access the study’s summary here.
-Children in care often suffer severe abuse or neglect;100,000 +children are in UK care (80,000+ in England).On average,10,000+/year go missing according to the survey made by the All Party Parliamentary Group;How many end up as slaves or sex toys we cannot know.
The judges,lawyers,and social workers always talk of rescuing children from future harm but never mention that the alternative “State Care” usually results in immediate emotional harm when they are forcibly separated from family and friends followed only too often by sexual abuse ,drugdealing,and a criminal career. No wonder their lives are shorter ……………..
LikeLiked by 3 people
This has been known & ignored for years. It doesn’t fit the social narrative which explains why it’s not acted upon. Instead of supporting families emotionally & financially the government would much rather billions were spent keeping the organisations afloat that send children into care regardless of how that will affect children.
I have no doubt there are some people who should never look after their own or anyone’s else children but they are a small percentage of the overall numbers of children taken into unnecessarily.
Maybe when this government has been brought to its knees financially due to this pandemic that common sense will prevail & children can go back to their homes & many less children taken in the first place.
LikeLiked by 1 person
no way, even during pandemic state gave 8 millions for adoption
LikeLiked by 1 person
What evidence to you have to support this assertion or are you just guessing and find it hard to believe that governments spend so much money on this?
LikeLike
Based on my own experiences of SS and care proceedings for example, as well as the experiences of others I know, I agree with you entirely. Local authorities complain of a shortage of funds for essential services, often resulting in cutting them completely, yet waste so much money on taking children from their parents unnecessarily and placing them in ‘care’, which clearly costs a great deal more than if they gave the parents the help needed in their circumstances. There must be some reason why they do this, but then they get quite an amount of money for each child they take, especially babies and very young children for adoption purposes to meet their targets.
LikeLike
Hi Natasha I am clicking through trying to read the summary but having issue with the link please can I ask I feel you have a copy of the report or another link you could send me many thanks Kate
LikeLike
Hi Kate, it looks like the publication has either been removed from the page or relocated. In any event, this was the best I could find: https://www.researchgate.net/project/Looked-after-children-grown-up
LikeLike
Thanks Natasha, I wondered if you recalled any studies or research regarding children with autism taken into care either with or without an autism diagnosis, and how they fare mental health wise with inadequate levels of contact, and also the issue of the LA blaming parents for a child’s development delay because they do not recognise autism in girls especially – many thanks for any help you can give me, I want to raise awareness of these issues both for my case and to help other families, thanks Kate
LikeLike
Hi Kate, the piece below is from the US, but Google is brilliant and if you do some searching I think you’ll find lots of information: https://www.spectrumnews.org/opinion/viewpoint/many-children-autism-end-foster-care/
LikeLike
Pingback: UK Study Confirms Poor Health For Care Experienced People, Reinforces Emerging Research | Researching Reform
Yet another well-researched and evidence based study confirming what is known ‘apocryphally’. I hope, but sadly don’t necessarily expect, that the impending(?) Care Review will consider this study along with others as well as considering ‘lived’ experience when it is eventually convened.
LikeLiked by 1 person